Becky Freeley gets a job as a guidance counselor at her old high school and assumes that her traumatic past is behind her, then learns that her high-school nemesis is the newly hired English teacher.
An attractive substitute teacher chooses Becky over Lisa, but his presence threatens Tim's job; one of Becky's troubled students gets exciting news.
A student's blog creates drama for the entire school; Becky feigns disinterest when she finds out that she is at the bottom of the "do-able" teachers list, but secretly tries to improve her ranking.
In an attempt to fit in with cool kids Tim and Lisa, Becky tries to rebel for the first time in her life by vandalizing Bruce's office.
Becky must plan a 40th anniversary party for the oldest and most-hated teacher in the school; Tim and Bruce realize they both have compromising relationships with Mrs. Pool.
Bruce assigns Becky, the least creative member of the faculty, to direct the school's musical.
Lisa asks Becky for dating advice; Bruce gives a rebellious student six months of detention for pulling the fire alarm.
