Michael and Joey, two former friends who have been estranged for 13 years after a falling out over a mutual love interest, discover that she had a child and one of them is the father.
After Michael forces the family to move into his apartment, Joey has a difficult time fitting into his uptown life, and Nicole has no playmates.
When Nicole and her best friend sneak out of the house to go to the movies in New Jersey, the dads try to agree on the most suitable punishment.
Nicole has her first date.
After Nicole sets Michael up on a date with a neighbor, he finds their relationship confusing when he can't decide whether they're dating or just friends.
Both Michael and Joey have dates on the same night, Nicole convinces them to let her stay home alone.
Joey is challenged by his father to sell a painting, or start working in the family plumbing business.
Michael's new love interest happens to be the Judge's niece, who is engaged.
Nicole receives a failing grade in Art.
Michael tries to spend time with Nicole, but when his career forces him to cancel dates with her, he starts feeling guilty about not being around her.
Joey and Michael are excited to celebrate Christmas with Nicole, but she wants to ignore the holiday because it will be her first without her mother.
Nicole complains about being an only child, but when her fathers get her a little brother, her plan backfires as she stops being the center of attention.
When Michael's mother comes to town for a special visit, she wrecks havoc on Joey's life and makes him miserable.
When Michael has a health scare during a training regime, Nicole becomes worried and demands that the loft's racquetball championship game be cancelled.
When Joey's rock star friend visits, he expresses his belief that Michael is a bad influence and Nicole should have more freedom, creating some tensions.
Cory seeks some guidance on kissing, so his older brother helps him, but he encourages him to make romantic propositions with Nicole to prove his manhood.
Nicole's dreams are shattered when her first modeling audition ends poorly, so Michael cheers her up by using his influence to land her a role in a commercial.
When Michael's sister comes to town for a visit, Michael is shocked to discover the reason she left her medical care was because of Joey.
When Nicole goes on a week-long camping trip, Michael and Joey begin feeling lonely and fear for her safety, so their friends decided to help them out.
When Joey wants to be presentable while meeting his new date's father, he asks for Michael's help; Michael meets the woman of his dreams.
A newspaper criticizes the Judge's decision to put Nicole with Michael and Joey. A TV reporter does a feature on the story.
