Cameron Deane Stewart
as Daniel Fisher
Jacob Blair
as Daniel Fisher
Sandra Van Natta
as Rebecca Lapp
Bill Oberst Jr.
as Samuel Lapp
Sherry Stringfield
as Laura Mayfield-Bennett
Adrian Paul
as Dylan Bennett
Chad Connell
as Justin Wirth
Michael Rupnow
as Justin Wirth
Katie Leclerc
as Katie Lapp / Katherine Mayfield
Danielle Panabaker
as Katie Lapp
Burgess Jenkins
as Bishop John Beiler
Nancy Saunders
as Ella Mae Zook
Julia Whelan
as Alyson
Rebecca Coon
as Rosie
Ray Collins
as Fulton