Patrick Dempsey
as Harry Quebert
Ben Schnetzer
as Marcus Goldman
Damon Wayans Jr.
as Sgt. Perry Gahalowood
Virginia Madsen
as Tamara Quinn
Kristine Frøseth
as Nola Kellergan
Colm Feore
as Elijah Stern
Joshua Close
as Luther Caleb
Matt Frewer
as Reverend Kellergan
Connor Price
as Young Travis Dawn
Tessa Mossey
as Young Jenny Quinn
Victoria Clark
as Jenny Quin
Craig Eldridge
as Travis Dawn
Kurt Fuller
as Police Chief Gareth Pratt
Don Harvey
as Bobbo Quinn
Wayne Knight
as Benjamin Roth