Stella Maeve
as Julia Wicker
Olivia Taylor Dudley
as Alice Quinn
Summer Bishil
as Margo Hanson
Hale Appleman
as Eliot Waugh
Jason Ralph
as Quentin Coldwater
Jade Tailor
as Kady Orloff-Diaz
Brittany Curran
as Fen
Arjun Gupta
as William "Penny" Adiyodi
Rick Worthy
as Dean Henry Fogg
Trevor Einhorn
as Josh Hoberman
Arjun Gupta
as William "Penny" Adiyodi (Timeline 23)
Hale Appleman
as The Monster
Rick Worthy
as Dean Fogg (Timeline 17)